Dual pricing at a register is familiar: a cash price and a card price, posted side by side. Online there is no cash, but there is something better for the business: ACH, a direct bank payment that costs a flat amount instead of a percentage. Put an ACH price and a card price on your payment page, let the customer pick, and the card cost stops coming out of your margin. This page covers how it works on a hosted payment page or payment link, what the customer sees, the card-brand and California rules, the risks of ACH, and how we set it up.
How dual pricing works on a payment page
A hosted payment page is a checkout page served by your gateway, not your website. The customer arrives from a button on your site, an emailed or texted payment link, or an invoice. Because the card and bank details are entered on the gateway’s page, your website never touches them, which keeps most businesses on the shortest PCI questionnaire. That part is covered on our hosted payment pages and PCI scope page.
Dual pricing adds one thing to that page: two totals.
- The regular price is the card price. That is the price you quote, the price on the order, and the amount charged when the customer pays by card.
- The ACH price is the discounted price. It is the card price less the discount for paying from a bank account.
- Both totals are visible before the customer enters payment details. The customer chooses the method, sees the matching total, and pays it.
- The receipt shows the amount paid and the method. No fee line, no adjustment line.
The business nets about the same amount either way. On ACH it receives the ACH price less a small flat ACH fee. On a card it receives the card price, and the difference between the two prices funds the cost of card acceptance.
What the customer sees
On a $2,500 order with a 3.99% card price, a dual-priced page reads like this:
| Payment method | Total |
|---|---|
| Pay by bank (ACH / eCheck) | $2,500.00 |
| Pay by credit or debit card | $2,599.75 |
Under the totals, one sentence does the explaining: “Our prices include the cost of card acceptance. Pay by bank transfer and save $99.75.” That is a discount for using a cheaper method, stated in plain words, before the customer commits.
A customer who wants card points or needs to pay on a company card pays $2,599.75 and moves on. A customer who would rather keep $99.75 pays by bank. Either way, nobody is surprised at the end of checkout.
Why ACH is so much cheaper than a card
Cards are priced as a percentage of the sale. Online and keyed card payments are card-not-present, which carries higher interchange than tapping a card at a counter because the fraud risk is higher. All-in, a small business usually pays 2.5% to 3.5% on an online card payment, and more on rewards and commercial cards.
ACH is priced per item. Through a gateway on a merchant account it is typically a flat 25 cents to $1.50 per payment, or a low percentage with a cap. The ACH network moves money between bank accounts without the card networks, so there is no percentage to pay. Our own ACH pricing is a flat per-item fee.
| Order size | Card at 2.99% | Card at 3.5% | ACH at a flat $1 |
|---|---|---|---|
| $300 | $8.97 | $10.50 | $1 |
| $2,500 | $74.75 | $87.50 | $1 |
| $10,000 | $299 | $350 | $1 |
The bigger the ticket, the more a percentage costs and the more ACH saves. Costs, timing and return codes are on our ACH payment gateway page.
A worked example: one $2,500 order
Same order, three setups. ACH at a flat $1 per payment is used for illustration. The card price is 3.99% above the ACH price.
| Card only, one price (today) | Dual pricing, paid by card | Dual pricing, paid by ACH | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price the customer sees | $2,500.00 | $2,599.75 card total | $2,500.00 ACH total |
| Customer pays | $2,500.00 | $2,599.75 | $2,500.00 |
| Processing cost | $74.75 at 2.99% | About $99.75, funded by the card price | $1.00 |
| Business nets | $2,425.25 | About $2,500 | $2,499.00 |
Twenty orders like this a month is $50,000 in online sales. Card-only at 2.99%, the business pays about $1,495 a month, or roughly $17,900 a year. With dual pricing, the card cost is funded by the card price and the business pays only the flat ACH fees on bank payments, a few dollars a month, plus whatever gateway fee it already pays.
How card-brand rules treat dual pricing online
Card-brand rules distinguish between adding a charge for using a card and giving a discount for using something else.
- A surcharge starts from one price and adds a fee when the customer pays by credit card. Visa caps it at 3%, it can never be applied to debit or prepaid cards, it requires 30 days’ written notice to your acquirer, and the receipt shows it as a separate line.
- A discount for a non-card method starts from the regular price, which is the card price, and takes money off for paying another way. Federal law (the Durbin Amendment) protects a merchant’s right to offer discounts for paying by cash, check or other methods, and the card brands permit it when it is clearly disclosed.
Dual pricing on a payment page is the second one. To keep it that way:
- The displayed card total is the regular price. You quote it, you invoice it, you charge it.
- Never label the difference as a “fee”, “surcharge”, “convenience fee”, “service fee” or “non-cash adjustment”. A line item with any of those names on top of a base price is a surcharge, whatever the program is called.
- Debit cards pay the card price. The discount is for paying from a bank account by ACH or eCheck, not for which kind of card is used.
- Show both totals before the customer enters payment details. Not after the card is entered, and not only on the receipt.
- Keep the card price close to your cost of acceptance. Most programs run 3.5% to 3.99%.
The full side-by-side of the three models is in dual pricing vs surcharging vs cash discount.
A proposed Visa and Mastercard settlement with merchants received preliminary court approval in June 2026 and would loosen some surcharging and steering rules if it is finally approved. As of this writing it is not final, and it would not change state law. Dual pricing does not depend on it.
California: Civil Code 1748.1 and SB 478
This is how we set it up, not legal advice. If your situation is unusual, ask a lawyer.
Civil Code 1748.1 says a retailer may not impose a surcharge on a consumer who elects to pay by credit card instead of cash, check or similar means. The same subdivision says a retailer may offer discounts to induce payment by cash, check or other means not involving a credit card, provided the discount is offered to all prospective buyers. An ACH discount offered to every customer on the payment page fits that language. A card fee added at checkout does not.
SB 478, California’s honest pricing law, took effect July 1, 2024. It prohibits advertising, displaying or offering a price that leaves out mandatory fees, other than government taxes and reasonable shipping. The Attorney General’s guidance says a credit card fee is not mandatory if the customer can avoid it by paying another way, but if a business accepts only credit cards, the fee is mandatory and must be in the advertised price.
That second point matters online. Most websites take cards only. A card-only site that adds a card fee at checkout is advertising a price the customer cannot actually pay. Adding ACH as a real alternative, and showing both totals before the customer chooses, means the price the customer sees is the price the customer pays, whichever method they pick.
Both laws are written for consumer transactions. We apply the same setup to business customers anyway, because it is clearer and it costs nothing extra. California specifics are in is dual pricing legal in California.
ACH risks, and how to manage them
ACH is cheaper, but it is not a card. Plan for these:
- No instant authorization. A card tells you in two seconds whether the money is there. ACH is submitted and settles in one to three business days.
- NSF returns. If the account is short, the payment comes back, usually within two business days. Most gateways can retry automatically.
- Unauthorized returns. A consumer can dispute an ACH debit as unauthorized for up to 60 days. Business accounts have a much shorter window. Your defense is the authorization record: the checkbox, the terms shown, the timestamp and IP address, which the hosted page stores.
- Account verification. Nacha rules have required businesses taking online (WEB) debits to validate a bank account the first time it is used since March 2021, and new fraud-monitoring rules phased in during 2026. Instant bank verification, where the customer logs into their bank instead of typing numbers, handles most of this and cuts wrong-account returns.
- Longer settlement. Do not ship goods, release a deliverable or start a large job until the ACH payment has cleared.
For a business with a long-term customer and a large ticket, these are small costs. For a first-time online buyer of a $2,500 item that ships today, a card may be the better risk, and the card price covers it.
Which businesses this fits
Dual pricing online pays off when tickets are large and customers have a bank account handy:
- B2B sellers and distributors. Business customers often prefer ACH already, and the ones on company cards pay the card price without complaint.
- Contractors and trades taking deposits and progress payments by payment link. The contractors and service businesses page covers the full setup.
- Professional services. Law firms, accountants, consultants, agencies, IT and managed services.
- Recurring billing. Memberships, retainers and maintenance plans, where a bank account on file does not expire. See recurring billing.
- High-ticket online orders. Equipment, furniture, custom work, tuition, events.
It matters less for a store with a $35 average order, where ACH saves about a dollar and adds settlement risk. For in-person sales, see dual pricing at the counter.
How we set it up on accept.blue or NMI
We place two gateways for this: accept.blue and NMI. Both process cards and ACH through the same hosted payment pages, payment links, virtual terminal and tokenized customer vault.
- Board the account with card processing and ACH on one merchant relationship and one bill, month to month.
- Configure the payment page or link with both card and bank payment enabled, your logo and colors, and the two totals labeled by method. How the totals are presented depends on the gateway and how the payment is created (button on your site, payment link, or invoice), and we confirm the exact presentation for your setup before you go live.
- Set the card price at a percentage that matches your cost of acceptance, usually 3.5% to 3.99%.
- Turn on bank verification and authorization capture for ACH, and set retry rules for NSF returns.
- Write the disclosure sentence for the page, the payment link message and your order confirmation.
- Run test payments by card, debit card and ACH and check each receipt for the right total and no fee line.
If you also bill by invoice, the same model applies to the invoice itself. That setup, including QuickBooks, is on dual pricing on invoices.
Dual pricing vs surcharging online
| Surcharge online | Dual pricing online | |
|---|---|---|
| Price shown first | One price, then a fee at checkout | Two totals before the customer chooses |
| Applies to debit cards | No, prohibited | Yes, debit pays the card price |
| Cap | 3% for Visa | No surcharge cap; set near cost of acceptance |
| Notice to acquirer | 30 days in writing | None |
| California consumer sales | Restricted under 1748.1 and awkward under SB 478 | Fits 1748.1’s discount allowance and SB 478’s full-price rule |
| Receipt | Base price plus surcharge line | Amount paid and method |
| What it recovers | Credit cards only | All cards |
On a $2,500 order with half the card payers on debit, a 3% surcharge recovers $75 from credit payers and nothing from debit payers. Dual pricing recovers the cost on every card and moves some customers to ACH, which costs a dollar.
Next step
Send us a recent processing statement through our free statement analysis and tell us how you take payments online. We reply with what card fees cost you today, what a dual-priced payment page would cost, and which gateway fits your website or billing software.